Board
Compensation
Warning: There is very little publicly available information on private company board compensation. The insights provided here are based on our observations and experience working on numerous board roles over the years. While not definitive, these guidelines have proven to be generally accurate and helpful for both companies and candidates.
Compensation for a high-growth, early-stage, private, consumer business should be all or a mix of the following:
- $0-40k cash per year
- 0.25% equity that vests over 4-5 years, with a reasonable belief that equity would be worth $50-100k per year of service in proceeds at exit
- Ability for the board member to invest in order to increase her ownership
- 15-20 hours of board-related service per quarter with all related expenses paid
When considering board compensation, we recommend that both companies and candidates think holistically about the entire package, not just focusing on equity. A comprehensive compensation package can include various components that provide value to board members and align their interests with the company's success. Here are some key elements to consider:
For early-stage companies, cash compensation is atypical. This presents an opportunity for companies to differentiate themselves by being thoughtful about cash compensation, if they can afford it. For example, typical board members spend 15-20 hours per quarter. If you want to incentivize your board member to spend a bit more time than that to, say, get involved in a special project or strategic initiative, we recommend considering compensating that board member with cash, in addition to equity. Typical cash compensation in this scenario is $10-20k annually, paid quarterly. For companies that cannot compensate in equity (for example: a business that has no intention or interest in selling, like a legacy, family-run business), typical cash starting point is $50k per year but varies widely up and down depending on the size (revenue, profitability) of the company.
A good rule of thumb is to aim for a board member's equity to be worth $50–100k per year of service at the time of exit. For early-stage companies, this often translates to about 0.25% ownership. However, it's more important to look beyond percentages and have a meaningful conversation about the company's vision and the mechanics of the security. There's a lot to consider: options vs. incentive units vs. RSUs, dilution, early exercise, ability to liquidate, QSBS, vesting schedule, and more. Rather than delving into technical details here, we've included several additional resources for further information below.
Allowing board members to invest in the company can create a win-win situation, increasing their commitment and potential upside. Are you attracting a particularly high-profile or successful board member and 0.25% equity (give or take) isn't enough? Consider inviting them to invest in the business. This approach allows them to increase their exposure to the company's success without requiring you to give up too much equity "for free".
Let’s bring it to life with an example…
Let’s say you’re considering an opportunity with a strong consumer brand that’s currently doing about $30M in revenue. When you joined the board, the company was valued at $100M. Over the five years you served on the board, the company grew tremendously and tripled its value to $300M and was acquired. Woo! That’s a pretty exceptional story!
At year 0, you were granted 0.25% equity and the company didn’t receive any additional outside investment that would have diluted your ownership.
Your 0.25% of equity would roughly be worth $500k for your five years of service. Or $100k annually.
Perhaps this is understood, but we believe it’s important to say bluntly: your equity could be worth nothing. It’s very possible that you spend a lot of blood, sweat, tears, time and energy supporting a business, and your equity compensation has no value by the end of it. At Women on Boards Project, we do our best to lightly diligence the companies we work with in order to prevent a “glass cliff” scenario. Or in other words, a scenario in which failure is more likely because you’re joining in a moment of crisis or downturn. That being said, a lot of factors contribute to a business failing and we can’t foresee them all. We want to ensure all candidates understand the risk.
Equity compensation is complicated and there’s a fear in asking “stupid” questions. We recommend consulting with counsel that’s savvy in both providing basic education but also explaining technical nuances. Prior to joining a board where equity is part of the conversation, you should feel comfortably versed in the mechanics of your compensation. We highly recommend the incredible team at Foster Garvey. We are more than happy to make this introduction for you.
In a scenario where the company does not “successfully” exit but some dollars do get returned to the investors, those dollars are negotiable. The leadership team and board members can (and often should) “fight for the little guys” or for the folks who poured their heart and soul into the company but won’t see any return on their equity. Investors may show an appetite to cut into their return in order to create a pool of dollars for transaction bonuses for employees, which incentivizes the team to work their ass off until the very end, even when they know it won’t be the outcome they all dreamed of. Board members can be considered within that pool too. Investors have an incentive to consider these transaction bonuses because references are often more valuable to them than the dollars (in other words, investors highly value the Founders, board members and employees saying favorable things about their experience working with them).